Legal advice to musicians, after “Blurred Lines”: pretend you have no influencesOn July 12, 2017 by Kenna
It’s been two years since Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke lost a lawsuit brought by Marvin Gaye’s descendants, who argued that their song “Blurred Lines” infringed Gay’s 1977 song “Got to Give It To You,” not because it copied the music per se, but because it copied its “vibe.”
Now, on the eve of Williams’ and Thicke’s appeal, the BBC reports that the verdict has had profound effects on the way that musicians talk about their compositions.
On the one hand, musicians are now being given legal advice not to admit to being influenced by anyone and to deny any inspiration from any source. On the other hand — and for the same reason — the labels’ legal departments are requiring disclosure forms that enumerate every possible influence or inspiration in the artist’s background, to prepare themselves for an eventual lawsuit.
The reality, of course, is that influence is how all art gets made (see Johnathan Lethem’s seminal 2007 essay “The Ecstasy of Influence” for more on this).
Moreover, music has always involved the kinds of takings that the Gaye estate sued over — Gaye himself would have never had a career if he’d been held to the standard that his descendants held Williams and Thicke to. As Jennifer Jenkins and James Boyle traced in their must-read, open access comic, “Theft: A History of Music”, musicians have always balanced on a knife-edge of contradiction, taking from other musicians to make their compositions and insisting that this is legitimate artistic progress — but suing and decrying other musicians who did this to them.
According to forensic musicologist Peter Oxendale “everyone’s concerned that inspiration can [now be interpreted as] a catalyst for infringement.
“All of these companies are worried that if a track is referenced on another at all, there may be a claim being brought,” he explains.
Mr Oxendale says some artists are now having the requirement to name their influences written into contracts by their record labels – although he would not specify names.
“Many of the companies that I work with ask the producers and the artists to declare all of the tracks that may have been used as inspiration for their new tracks,” he says.
He also confirmed that he is being sent new music to check the possibility of future copyright infringement claims.
Is the threat of a copyright lawsuit stifling music?
[Chi Chi Izundu/BBC]
From 1993 to 2001, this Serbian middle-school biology textbook sported a cutout of a still from Raising Arizona in which Nicholas Cage and Holly Hunter cradle their stolen baby.
Vidangel is the latest attempt (along with services like Clearplay and Sony’s own filtering tool) to sell a product that allows cringing, easily triggered evangelicals to skip swear words, sex and blasphemy in the media they watch.
On Thingiverse, Gentlegiant’s beautiful, faithful model of the Haunted Mansion front-gate sign to 3D print at any size or remix into your other designs.
Amazon’s Prime Day is one of the most clever user acquisition schemes on the web, echoing the mission of hallowed holidays like Black Friday and Cyber Monday. People like to shop. That’s cool, and Prime Day mines deep into the Amazon product labyrinth to drop prices on things you probably didn’t even know existed, let […]
If you are a UI designer, creating custom icons is often more trouble than it’s worth since you probably already spent an inordinate amount of time dealing with a range of application states, device sizes, and UX guidelines. Instead of reinventing the wheel for every project, consider using assets from Icons8.Icons8 is a massive online […]
Python is one of the most robust programming languages around, but that doesn’t mean it’s strictly for experts. Thanks to its versatility and elegant, human-readable syntax, Python is a great starter language for novices, and has significant applications for data scientists and web developers alike. To get up to speed with this powerful language, or […]